Keurig K50 Vs. K200: Which One is Suitable for You?

A huge chunk of the single-serve coffee makers on the market today are from Keurig, and this shows just how popular the brand has become over the years.

However, with that many products in the market, many coffee lovers will end up having difficulties deciding what to buy, and this is more so when faced with two models that are quite similar such as the Keurig K50 and K200.

While one represents the classic Keurig brewing and the other is a more modern version of the Keurig brewing system, choosing between these two amazing coffee makers is still a confusing task.

However, we are here to ensure you can easily tell which model between the two will serve you well. And we do this with overviews of the two and by comparing them side by side.

Keurig K50 Overview

Keurig K50

Keurig K50 is from Keurig’s older line of coffee makers the Keurig 1.0, and hence it will come in a more classic look, and it also looks and feels bulkier than their modern coffee maker options.

This coffee maker has been one of their most popular single-serve models for quite some time now, and many users love the relatively larger 48-ounce water reservoir. Also, many find it very convenient because, besides the Keurig pods, it can also work with other unofficial K-Cups.

When compared to the K200, it is also a significantly more affordable coffee maker, and so it will appeal to the many budget shoppers.

And despite being an older model, it still has various impressive features to offer such as an auto shut off which makes it safer to operate and a removable drip tray that helps make cleanups quicker and easier.

However, this older coffer maker also lacks some modern Keurig coffee maker features such as coffee strength control and a water filter. Also, when you compare it to modern devices like the K200, it will be noisier when brewing something which many coffee drinkers will not like.

Pros:

  • Larger water tank
  • Tried and tested classic coffee maker
  • Auto shut off
  • Highly affordable
  • Removable drip tray

Cons:

  • Coffee strength not controllable
  • No water filter
  • Quite noisy

Keurig K200 Overview

Keurig K200

Keurig K200 is from the more recent Keurig 2.0 series, which is also one of their most successful series based on the popularity of the coffee makers in this line.

While the K50 provides a more classic Keurig performance, the K200 is more about keeping things modern, and it will give users some more advanced features that are meant to make coffee making easier.

Key among these features is a touch screen display that will make operation easier. Also, this coffee maker has been designed to accommodate all kinds of coffee drinkers because, besides offering more brew sizes, it will also accommodate several K-Mug and carafe options.

Adjusting the brew strength is also possible with this model, which means you can make your coffee just how you like it. And you will no longer have to use hard or unclean water as it will come with a charcoal filter.

But, as expected, all these modern features will come at a cost as this is a relatively more expensive option when compared to the K50. Also, despite this being a modern coffee maker, it will not work with many 3rd part pods which can be very restrictive.

Pros:

  • Sleeker and more modern look
  • Allows for brew strength adjustment
  • More convenient touchscreen display
  • Wider variety of brew sizes
  • Allows for brewing into a carafe

Cons:

  • Relatively pricier
  • Will not work with many 3rd party pods

Comparison Chart


Keurig K50

Keurig K200

Appearance

Bulky, classic look

Sleek, modern look

Water Reservoir Capacity

48 oz

40 oz

Brew Sizes

6, 8 and 10 oz

4, 6, 8 and 10 oz and up to 30 oz carafe

Display

Button controls

Touchscreen

Strength Control

No

Yes

Pod Compatibility

Both Keurig and 3rd party

Keurig only

Water Filter

No

Yes

Weight and Dimensions

7.6 lbs, 13” x 9.8” x 13.3”

7.5 lbs, 9” x 15” x 13.7”

Price

$

$$

Keurig K50 vs. Keurig K200

Choosing between the Keurig K50 and K200 might look very straightforward because they come from two different series, and they also have significantly different designs. But, the choice is not always that easy for many coffee lovers. However, here are a few points to keep in mind that will ensure you have an easier time deciding what to buy.

1. Appearance

A coffee maker’s appearance is often the first thing that draws your attention to it and is hence one of the main determinants of whether you buy it or not.

With these two coffee makers, you should not have any difficulties deciding which one to buy when it comes to the appearance as they look quite different.

Keurig K50 comes in a more classic look, and it also looks relatively bulkier like older version Keurig machines. K200, on the other hand, comes in a sleek, modern look, and it is also more minimalistic. Here, your tastes should help you decide which one will look best in your kitchen.

2. Water Reservoir Capacity

For many coffee lovers, the capacity of the water reservoir is one of the main factors that they will consider when choosing a coffee maker. When compared to other models in the same category from other brands, both Keurig K50 and K200 have some decent size reservoirs.

However, the older K50 seems to carry the day here as it has a 48-ounce reservoir which holds up to 8 ounces more than the K200 which comes with a 40-ounce reservoir.

The 8-ounce difference means that you will be able to make at least one more cup of coffee with the K50 before you need to refill the reservoir which in some instances will be a significant advantage.

Also, one more thing worth noting is that the water reservoirs in both coffee makers are removable which means refills and cleaning will be easier.

3. Brew Sizes

Brew size also matters because you need a coffee machine that can make as much coffee as you like taking or can make enough to fill up your favorite mug or cup.

Keurig seems to have made this observation over the years as most of its modern coffee makers like the K200 will provide a wide variety of brew sizes to suit all users. With the K200, you can make brew sizes between 4 and 30 ounces and brew K-Cups, K-mugs and the K-carafe in different sizes.

K50 does not give you this versatility because it will only have three brew size which are 6, 8 and 10 ounces. Also, this coffee machine will neither brew the mugs or carafe which can be inconvenient for many modern coffee drinkers.

4. Display

The display is another clear difference between these two coffee makers as they have different kinds of controls. But, even before getting to the specific displays and control, it is worth mentioning that both are still quite easy to use.

K50 is a classic Keurig coffee machine, and so you should not expect it to have any fancy displays. Instead, this coffee maker relies on a button control panel for controlling the brew size and power. But, it also includes handy LED lights for refill and descaling alerts.

K200 will use a touchscreen that you can use to control the drink type and also do other things such as strength selection and choose a brew size. Also, this display will alert you when you need to change the filter and when running out of water.

5. Strength Control

Strength control is one of the key advantages that the K200 has over the K50 as it will allow you to make your coffee just how you like it.

And with the touchscreen display, choosing the strength that you prefer will also be quick and easy. However, it is worth mentioning that like with many other budget models in the Keurig 2.0 series, this feature will only work well when using the 2.0 pods.

With the K50, you will only be able to choose your brew size, and so to determine whether your coffee will be mild or strong, you will need to get a little creative with the quantity of coffee and water.

6. Pod Compatibility

Pod compatibility will affect the convenience and cost of using either of these coffee makers. And so it should be at the top of your mind when deciding which one to buy.

Keurig K50 seems to be the better option here as, besides the K-Cups, it can also work well enough with the unofficial pods. What this means is that if you find what Keurig has to offer pricier for you, it is possible to use cheaper generic types.

While it is still possible to use 3rd party pods on the K200, it seems to work much better with Keurig pods.

Also, both coffee machines are compatible with the K-Cup Reusable Filters, which means you can also use them to brew using ground coffee. And they can handle tea and hot cocoa which makes them quite versatile.

7. Water Filter

Because the quality of your water will have a huge impact on the coffee taste, it is vital to use the best quality possible when brewing.

The fact that the K200 comes with a charcoal filter means you will get better quality and impurity-free water when using it, and hence better-tasting coffee. Because this filter also helps soften the water significantly, it will also be perfect for those that live in places with hard water.

While the filter comes with an extra cost of buying a replacement and extra work of cleaning it, this is a small price to pay to get great tasting coffee. K50 will not come with any filter and neither is it compatible with one.

8. Weight and Dimensions

These are both single-serve coffee makers, and so even before you see them, you can be sure that they will be relatively smaller than most other coffee maker types.

But, both their weight and dimensions will be different, and you can tell just by looking at them at first glass.

Keurig K50 is a bulky-looking coffee maker, and its dimensions are 13 x 9.8 x 13.3 inches, which means it will still not take up as much counter space as it might seem. Also, this coffee maker weighs just 7.6 pounds.

K200 has a more minimalistic appearance, but it is almost the same size as the K50 as its dimensions are 9 x 15 x 13.7 inches, and it weighs around 7.5 pounds. But, because both are under 10 pounds, they should be lightweight and portable enough.

9. Price

Being the older model of the two, K50 is also the cheaper option. Also, its relatively smaller price tag stems from the fact that it is a more classic coffee maker with no fancy features like a touchscreen or a sleek design.

But, these two are still more budget-friendly coffee makers, and when compared to similar models that other brands have to offer, they will give you great value for money regardless of which between the two you choose.

At the time of writing this piece, the Keurig K50 was on average around $50 more affordable than the K200. And to sum up the prices, the K50 is a low price range coffee maker while the K200 is a mid-range model.

Conclusion

When comparing two popular coffee maker models from a reputable and trustworthy brand like Keurig, there will not be a clear winner. Hence, between the K50 and K200, no model comes outright at the top of the other, and so the choice mostly depends on your preferences.

The kind of coffee drinker you are, the kinds of brews you make and also the volume of coffee you consume should help you decide which one between these two models will work well for you. And our overview above makes it clear what gives each an edge over the other.

From our comparison, it is clear that the K200 will be a perfect option for anyone looking for a sleek, modern-looking coffee machine. Keurig K50, on the other hand, is the thing for you if you prefer something more classic, with a larger water reservoir, and comes with a smaller price tag.