10 Best Coffee Creamers – Reviews & Buying Guide
For coffee purists, a good cup of coffee means taking it black without even adding sweeteners, but for the typical daily coffee drinkers, coffee is not complete without some creamer.
Creamer gives coffee a rich and thick taste while also improving its texture. But, like with everything else that concerns coffee, you have to use the best coffee creamer to truly enjoy your beverage.
The good news is that there is a seemingly endless supply of both dairy and non-dairy coffee creamers out there that claim to have the ability to take your coffee-taking experience a notch higher.
But, to truly pick a coffee creamer that will enhance your coffee's flavor and taste, you need to have the right information. This means you need to know the different types available, their flavors and taste.
In this piece, we explain the important things to keep in mind when choosing coffee creamers, but first here are our reviews of 10 top-rated coffee creamers.
- 10 Best Coffee Creamers – Reviews
- 1. Nestle Coffee Mate Coffee Creamer
- 2. Nestle Coffee Mate Liquid Coffee Creamer
- 3. Left Coast Performance Keto Coffee Creamer
- 4. Coffee Booster High-Fat Coffee Creamer
- 5. Omega PowerCreamer Keto Coffee Creamer
- 6. Laird Superfood Non-Dairy Coffee Creamer
- 7. International Delight Single-Serve Coffee Creamer
- 8. Bulletproof Instamix Coffee Creamer
- 9. BPI Sports Keto Coffee Creamer
- 10. Member's Mark Non-Diary Coffee Creamer
- How to Buy the Best Coffee Creamer
10 Best Coffee Creamers – Reviews
1. Nestle Coffee Mate Coffee Creamer
Rich and great tasting non-dairy coffee creamer that does not have any cholesterol or lactose and with an all-natural formulation and flavor with no gluten at all
2. Nestle Coffee Mate Liquid Coffee Creamer
An amazing coffee creamer that allows you to enjoy classic vanilla on your cup of coffee, and it is also gluten and cholesterol-free creamer formulated to be shelf-stable prior to opening
3. Left Coast Performance Keto Coffee Creamer
Premium quality creamer that will be perfect for ketogenic thanks to the zero carbs and no sugar formulation, and it is also gluten-free and more lactose-friendly
4. Coffee Booster High-Fat Coffee Creamer
An exceptionally tasty, ghee based coffee creamer formulated with all natural and non-GMO ingredients, and it is designed to be ideal for all kinds of diets, and it dissolves and mixes with your beverage well and does not require any refrigeration
5. Omega PowerCreamer Keto Coffee Creamer
A more diet-friendly coffee creamer that is still flavorful and delicious and is made from all natural, non-GMO ingredients and is also easy to use and store as it does not require refrigeration
6. Laird Superfood Non-Dairy Coffee Creamer
Unsweetened but tasty creamer that is made from all natural and non-GMO ingredients and is gluten-free, completely non-dairy and will be perfect for both keto and paleo diet programs
7. International Delight Single-Serve Coffee Creamer
Single-serve packaged creamer that you can use from anywhere, and it has been formulated to offer delightful flavors and is a shelf-stable product that is quite versatile and easy to use
8. Bulletproof Instamix Coffee Creamer
Delicious and creamy dairy-based creamer that is made for use on the go as it comes in a travel-friendly packaging and will not require blending, and it is also ideal for other beverages like tea and cocoa and is formulated to keep cravings in check
9. BPI Sports Keto Coffee Creamer
Perfect coffee creamer for those on a weight loss program but still wish to enjoy some delightful coffee, and it is also a sugar-free and low carb product that boosts energy and performance
10. Member's Mark Non-Diary Coffee Creamer
With lots of creamer in the container, this product is designed to provide great value for cash, and it is rich, perfectly textured, creamy and flavorful for an amazing cup of coffee
Rich and great tasting creamer
Editor's Rating: (4.6 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
With a few spoons of this top-rated coffee creamer by Nestle, your daily cup of coffee will always be richer and creamier to give you that perfect start to a day.
Like with many of their other creamers. Nestle uses an all-natural formulation that makes it safer and ideal for use even for individuals with health issues.
What many coffee lovers will like most about this creamer is that besides being completely gluten-free, it also does not have any lactose and cholesterol.
And to ensure that you get great value for your cash, each container contains enough coffee creamer for at least 35 servings. There is also no after taste, the creamer mixes into the coffee well and will also not leave any stains on the cup.
While this cream seems to take a few extra spoons to bring out the flavor, this should not be a deal breaker given that there is a lot of it in the container and the fact that it is all natural means it will not have any adverse effect when you take lots of it.
Classic vanilla taste in your cup of coffee
Editor's Rating: (4.3 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
A classic vanilla flavor like what you get from this Nestle creamer will give you one more reason to look forward to your daily caffeine fix.
The rich tasting flavor of the creamer will help enhance your overall coffee taking experience and give you the perfect start to your day.
But, besides being tasty, this non-dairy coffee creamer has been formulated to be ideal for all kinds of coffee drinkers as it is gluten and lactose-free. And it is also a healthier coffee enhancer given that it is completely cholesterol-free.
Being the cheapest options among our coffee creamer reviews, this Nestle product will also ensure you get to save some cash, and it is also shelf-stable prior to opening which allows you to buy several bottles for an even better value for cash.
Given that the coffee creamer still has sodium caseinate which is a milk derivative, it is not completely non-dairy, but the good news is that the percentage is less than 2% which is not very significant.
The premium quality ketogenic coffee creamer
Editor's Rating: (4.2 / 5)
- Type: Dairy
If you are on a ketogenic diet but would still want to take coffee with some creamer, Left Coast Performance has you covered with this amazing coffee creamer.
This MCT and coconut oil-based coffee creamer will also include ghee butter and cacao, and it has been formulated to be carbs-free and does not have any sugar or other sweeteners.
The gluten-free and lactose-friendly creamer will be suitable for almost anyone included those that have minor lactose intolerance as the ghee butter will not cause GI distress.
And if you love bulletproof coffee, this will be the perfect creamer for you as it will make it not only easier to make but also provides the perfect texture.
While it is true the need to blend this creamer will add one more step to your coffee making, it only takes some getting used as you will hardly even notice the extra work involved as you use it more and more. Furthermore, the amazing taste makes it worth a little extra effort.
Exceptionally tasty ghee-based coffee creamer
Editor's Rating: (4 / 5)
- Type: Dairy
Coffee creamers do not have to be boring whether you are on a diet or not, and this exceptionally tasty one by Coffee Booster proves this.
It is a ghee-based high-fat creamer that will ensure you get the heaviest coffee creamer on your cup of coffee, and it also contains raw cacao powder and all natural coconut oil.
Also, all the ingredients used to make the creamer are natural and non-GMO to make it even healthier, but its full flavor and amazing taste are still what many coffee drinkers will love most.
This creamer is also super easy to use as it dissolves and mixes in well and it will be perfect for your diet plan whether it is paleo or ketogenic. And because it does not require refrigeration, storing it should also be super easy.
For those that are on a ketogenic diet, this coffee creamer still has significant amounts of sugar and carbs, but unless you put an excessive amount of it on your coffee, this should not be a significant concern.
Keto-friendly but still delicious coffee creamer
Editor's Rating: (3.9 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
Contrary to what some coffee drinkers tend to assume, there are many coffee creamers out there that will be both diet-friendly and delicious.
What makes it one of the best coffee creamers for diets like ketogenic, paleo and low carb is the fact that it has a high-fat content and has been formulated from all-natural and organic ingredients that include 100% grass-fed ghee.
This creamer is also cheaper per serving than most similar quality ones, and it will blend and froth easily to make it easy to use, and storage should also not take a lot of effort as it does not require any refrigeration.
Given the high-fat content on this creamer, it can be a little too greasy for the liking of some coffee lovers, but in most instances, the greasiness is often a result of using too much of it.
Unsweetened but flavorful and tasty
Editor's Rating: (3.9 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
Despite being unsweetened, this Laird Superfood product is one of the best-tasting coffee creamers on our list, and you can be confident it will make your cup of coffee more flavorful.
Besides, the great taste, this creamer has been formulated from all-natural and non-GMO ingredients to make it healthier, and it is also gluten-free and vegan-friendly.
This completely non-dairy coffee creamer has also been formulated with diet plans such as paleo and ketogenic in mind, and it will give coffee drinkers that extra energy boost they need to face the day ahead.
There is also no soy on this creamer or artificial additives which most coffee drinkers hate, and it is also relatively easy to use and store.
While this creamer might not be as creamy as the dairy-based options, you can still make your coffee creamy enough by adding a few extra spoons of it.
Delightful flavor in a convenient single-serve package
Editor's Rating: (4.1 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
With this conveniently packaged single-serve creamer, you can enjoy creamy and great tasting coffee from anywhere as it will be super easy to carry around.
Also, the creamer is quite versatile as you can use it on various other beverages like hot chocolate and tea beside coffee. And you can stir it in, freeze it or steam it for easy use.
The rich in flavor coffee creamer is also shelf-stable to ensure that you do not have to refrigerate it which makes it more convenient.
This coffee creamer also allows you to choose from several flavor options which makes it easy to find something that appeals to your taste buds.
Although it might be a little expensive per serving, the quality and flavor that you get from this creamer make it worth paying a few extra bucks.
Perfect on the go coffee creamer
Editor's Rating: (3.7 / 5)
- Type: Dairy
For the coffee lovers that want a convenient coffee creamer for use on-the-go or when traveling, the Bulletproof Instamix is a perfect choice.
The travel-friendly package and the fact that it does not require blending will make it ideal for use from almost anywhere by simply mixing it into your beverage.
Besides coffee, this delicious and creamy flavor coffee creamer will also be ideal for use on other beverages like cocoa and tea.
Also, users will love the fact that besides providing a steady, all-day energy boost, it is also effective in keeping cravings in check which is vital for your diet plan to work.
Given its price per serving, this coffee creamer seems to have a surprisingly lower amount of fat which might be a significant shortcoming for those on diet plans. But blending in a little oil or butter into it should provide the fat you need.
Simple but effective coffee creamer for weight loss
Editor's Rating: (3.5 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
The fact that you are on a weight loss program does not mean you cannot enjoy some nice creamer on your cup of coffee because this one by BPI Sports will fit perfectly into your program.
It is a low-carb and sugar-free creamer has been formulated to boost energy and performance throughout the day and will help burn fat for fuel to support your weight loss program.
Also, you get to choose from a variety of flavor options which makes it ideal for almost anyone, and it can also be used for other beverages like tea and hot chocolate.
With the blend of electrolytes on this creamer, it will also be handy for enhancing athletic performance as it will fuel both the body and brain.
Despite this being a sugar-free coffee creamer, it can still be a little too sweet for some users, but you can easily make it less sweet on your beverage by using half a scoop instead of a full scoop.
Great value for cash
Editor's Rating: (3.8 / 5)
- Type: Non-dairy
By having more creamer in the container, Member’s Mark aims to ensure that you get great value for cash as it will be many weeks before you need to buy any other creamer.
Besides giving you one of the best values for cash among our coffee creamer reviews, this product is also one of the creamiest, and it has been formulated to be completely cholesterol and lactose-free to make it ideal for anyone.
The rich and perfectly textured creamer is also ideal for use in other beverages like tea beside coffee and even on desserts, and it will mix in easily.
The taste would do with some improvement as many coffee lovers do not find it very delicious. But like most other creamers, it only takes some getting used to, and you will probably even love it after some time.
How to Buy the Best Coffee Creamer
Given that coffee is the second most widely consumed beverage globally, you can be certain that there will always be many options to choose from when buying anything coffee-related and creamers are not an exception.
While there are many good coffee creamers in the market, there are almost as many substandard and unhealthy ones. Hence, to make sure you pick something that not only enhances your coffees texture and flavor but is also good for your health, you need to keep the points below in mind.
#1. Types of Coffee Creamer
Before you start even shopping for coffee creamer, the first thing should always be to understand what they are all about. And one of the most important things to know here are the different types available.
Typically, different brands will give their products different names and while there are many creamer types available, the four most common ones are half and half, light cream, whipping cream and heavy cream
Half and Half
Half and half is by far the most popularly used coffee creamer in the US and across most countries in Europe.
As its name indicates, it is made with half milk and half cream. And with a fat content of about 12%, half and half is thicker and sweeter than whole milk.
However, half and half will not have the thickness of whipping cream or pure whole cream. But, if you prefer a creamer that will give you a perfect balance of thickness and sweetness, half and half is one of the best options.
Some coffee drinkers will find that half and half creamer or even whole milk is not thick enough or their beverages.
When this is the case for you, going for light cream is a great idea as it will help you increase the fat content just a little bit which makes it thicker.
Light cream will have a fat content of about 20% which means you will be taking in more calories, but it is still nowhere close to the calories you get on the heavier creams.
Whipping cream is one of the thickest coffee creamers you can get, and it will contain at least 35% fat which means it packs a lot of calories.
It is much thicker than both half and half and the light cream, and it will be great for coffee drinkers looking for something with a thicker and creamier consistency.
But, also note that there is a light whipping cream version with around 30% fat which makes it heavier than light cream but not as thick as the regular whipping cream.
For those shopping for the best creamer for coffee and want something that is as thick and heavy as possible, the heavy cream will be the best bet. It is the thickest and heaviest cream that you can get out there thanks to the at least 38% fat content.
Heavy cream is also very rich and adding it to your cup of coffee can enhance its flavor and texture greatly. But, you need to be careful with how much you use because using too much can make your coffee a little too thick.
#2. Flavor and taste
In addition to their nutritional differences, different coffee creamers will also have varying flavors which means that the overall taste of the coffee will also differ.
For heavy cream, it will be thick and with a rich flavor but if it is natural with no additives, it will not be sweet.
With half and half you get a taste that is quite similar to fresh milk but it will be a little creamier and also a little bit more flavorful.
Also, the flavor and taste that you get on your coffee creamer will depend on the flavor additives used by the manufacturer, and some of the most common ones are hazelnut, vanilla, chai latte, and caramel.
#3. Dairy vs. Non-dairy
As you try to pick the perfect creamer for your coffee, you will also need to decide whether to go for dairy or the non-dairy based creamers.
Dairy creamers will be made from dairy products and will typically have milk or milk by-products in them, and so they might not be ideal for people that do not take milk due to allergies and other health issues or are strict vegetarians.
For vegans, the non-dairy creamers are the best alternative given that they are made from plant-based milk such as almond and coconut milk. Non-dairy creamers are also ideal for those that prefer something that is low carb.
Coffee creamers provide a simple but effective way of enhancing your coffee's taste, flavor, and texture, and they are also one of the best ways to make your brew a little milder.
But, if you are going to use creamer on your coffee, you need to make sure that you settle for nothing less than the best by considering things like the type, flavor, and taste when choosing.
Also, this piece makes it even easier to find the best coffee creamer by review 10 top notch options. All you need to do now is pick one that impresses you most as there is something for all kinds of coffee drinkers in our reviews above.
Read More: 10 Best Coffee Syrups