CoffeeGearX is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

10 Best Coffee Carafes 2019 – Reviews and Buying Guide

Best Coffee Carafe

If you ask most expert baristas about the secret to a tasty coffee, they will tell you that the serving temperature matters the most.

Indeed, we often concentrate more on the brewing process of coffee but tend to neglect the most vital aspect, the serving temperature.

Coffee served at almost the same temperature that it has been brewed will be the tastiest and most aromatic that it can be. Alternatively, there are many people who prefer to drink their coffee very cold.

This is where the coffee carafe comes into play. It is a coffee accessory that preserves the temperature of your hot or cold coffee for an extended period of time.

If you are looking for one, our coffee carafe review below lists some quality carafes that are well worth it.

You can also read other product reviews of coffee thermospour over kettleelectric gooseneck kettleelectric kettle for coffee

10 Best Coffee Carafes – Reviews

IMAGE

​PRODUCT

​FEATURES

Cresimo Thermal Coffee Carafe

1. Cresimo Double Walled (Large Capacity and Decent Heat Retention)

  • Large capacity of 2 L
  • The excellent heat retention of 12 hours for hot and 24 hours for cold
  • Made from 18/8 stainless steel
  • Proven 1-year warranty
Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe

2. Pykal PYX012S (Popular Model for Any Type of Coffee Drinker)

  • Versatile and can be used by anyone
  • The decent capacity of 2 L
  • Long hot and cold retention time
  • Spout designed in a way to prevent a spill
Cresimo Airpot Thermal Coffee Carafe

3. Cresimo Airpot Thermal (Superior Capacity and Easy to Use)

  • Very large capacity of 3 L
  • Pump action handle is easy to use
  • The above-average heat retention
Keurig Double-Walled Thermal Coffee Carafe

4. Keurig 2.0 Thermal (Compatible with the Keurig 2.0 Brewing System)

  • Compatible with Keurig 2.0 brewing system
  • Affordable and good value
  • Durable stainless-steel build construction
Bellemain Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe

5. Bellemain Premium Thermal (Affordable and Good Value)

  • Affordable and value for money
  • The decent capacity of 2 L for the price
  • Solid build construction
Thermos Vacuum Insulated Coffee Carafe

6. Thermos Vacuum Insulated (Available in Different Sizes)

  • You can purchase it in different sizes
  • The outer shell is always cool
  • Easy to use with 1 hand
Panesor Thermal Coffee Carafe

7. Panesor Thermal Insulated (Coffee Carafe that Retrofits as a Water Kettle)

  • Flexible. Can also be used as a kettle
  • Comes in different colors
  • Auto shut-off and blue LED indicator
Genuine Joe GJO11956 Coffee Carafe

8. Genuine Joe GJO11956 (Most Affordable Coffee Carafe)

  • Most affordable coffee carafe
  • Can be purchased as a 2-pack
  • Secure lever prevents accidental spills
Zojirushi AFB Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe

9. Zojirushi AFB Premium (Easy to Handle with One Hand)

  • It can easily be operated with 1 hand
  • Durable build construction
  • Comes in different sizes
Vremi 51 oz Coffee Carafe

10. Vremi VRM020037N (Aesthetically Pleasing and Available in Different Colors)

  • Aesthetically pleasing design
  • It can be purchased in different colors
  • The decent capacity of 1.5 L

PRODUCT

1. Cresimo Double Walled 

(Large Capacity and Decent Heat Retention)

Cresimo Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Large capacity of 2 L
  • The excellent heat retention of 12 hours for hot and 24 hours for cold
  • Made from 18/8 stainless steel
  • Proven 1-year warranty

2. Pykal PYX012S 

(Popular Model for Any Type of Coffee Drinker)

Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Versatile and can be used by anyone
  • The decent capacity of 2 L
  • Long hot and cold retention time
  • Spout designed in a way to prevent a spill

3. Cresimo Airpot Thermal 

(Superior Capacity and Easy to Use)

Cresimo Airpot Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Very large capacity of 3 L
  • Pump action handle is easy to use
  • The above-average heat retention

4. Keurig 2.0 Thermal 

(Compatible with the Keurig 2.0 Brewing System)

Keurig Double-Walled Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Compatible with Keurig 2.0 brewing system
  • Affordable and good value
  • Durable stainless-steel build construction

5. Bellemain Premium Thermal 

(Affordable and Good Value)

Bellemain Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Affordable and value for money
  • The decent capacity of 2 L for the price
  • Solid build construction

6. Thermos Vacuum Insulated 

(Available in Different Sizes)

Thermos Vacuum Insulated Coffee Carafe
  • You can purchase it in different sizes
  • The outer shell is always cool
  • Easy to use with 1 hand

7. Panesor Thermal Insulated 

(Coffee Carafe that Retrofits as a Water Kettle)

Panesor Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Flexible. Can also be used as a kettle
  • Comes in different colors
  • Auto shut-off and blue LED indicator

8. Genuine Joe GJO11956 

(Most Affordable Coffee Carafe)

Genuine Joe GJO11956 Coffee Carafe
  • Most affordable coffee carafe
  • Can be purchased as a 2-pack
  • Secure lever prevents accidental spills

9. Zojirushi AFB Premium 

(Easy to Handle with One Hand)

Zojirushi AFB Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • It can easily be operated with 1 hand
  • Durable build construction
  • Comes in different sizes

10. Vremi VRM020037N 

(Aesthetically Pleasing and Available in Different Colors)

Vremi 51 oz Coffee Carafe
  • Aesthetically pleasing design
  • It can be purchased in different colors
  • The decent capacity of 1.5 L

1. Cresimo Double Walled ​– Large ​Capacity and ​Decent ​Heat ​Retention

Cresimo Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 2 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 12 hours hot and 24 hours cold

The Cresimo uses a vacuum insulation lock that ensures that is able to provide heat retention of 12 hours for hot coffee and 24 hours for cold coffee. Those values are pretty good which makes the Cresimo one of the best thermal coffee carafes on the market, especially considering its high capacity of 2 L.

In addition, this carafe is made from a surgical 18/8 stainless steel for both the interior as well as the exterior. This ensures that it is extremely durable and long-lasting and will serve you for years to come.

Even better, due to the stainless-steel build construction of this coffee carafe, it is very easy to clean by either a wet or dry cloth.

To make it an even sweeter deal, the manufacturer offers no less than ​1-year warranty on this coffee carafe. You have absolutely nothing to lose!

The only caveats here are the price, which is a little high and its plastic lid. It's definitely not the most durable lid we have seen but it gets the job done.

Pros:

  • The decent capacity of 2 L
  • 18/8 stainless steel on both the interior and exterior
  • The long heat retention of 12 hours for hot and 24 hours for cold coffee
  • Solid one-year warranty

Cons:

  • Price could have been a little bit more competitive
  • The lid is made of plastic and not very durable

Notes

The heat retention of this coffee carafe is effective only when it is full. If you plan to store only a small amount of coffee, then the mentioned heat retention will be significantly less than advertised

2. Pykal ​PYX012S ​– ​Popular Model for ​Any Type of Coffee Drinker

Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 2 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 24 hours

The Pykal is a popular coffee carafe that is used by both experts and beginner baristas. What demarks this product from the rest of the competition is its double-walled insulation that ensures efficient heat retention of 24 hours for both hot and cold coffee.

Moreover, this coffee carafe is made from stainless steel, so it is quite durable. To help you clean the coffee carafe more efficiently, the manufacturer ships this model with a special brush that allows you to easily clean the interior.

What we also like about this model is its specially designed spout that will prevent spillage from occurring.

The only caveat we note with this product is that the handle ​position makes it a little bit awkward to hold. Especially considering that this coffee carafe has a high capacity of 2 L ​so it is quite heavy when full.

Also, since it is made from metal, this handle conducts heat and can get a bit hot to the touch.

Pros:

  • High capacity of 2 L
  • Comes with a brush for cleaning the interior
  • The very long heat retention of 24 hours for both hot and cold coffee
  • Its spout is designed in a way to prevent spillage

Cons:

  • The handle is located at an awkward position
  • The handle can get a bit hot

3. Cresimo Airpot Thermal ​– ​Superior Capacity and ​Easy​ to​ Use

Cresimo Airpot Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 3 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 12 hours hot and 24 hours cold

Few models can beat the Cresimo when it comes to capacity. Indeed, this coffee carafe can hold an impressive amount of coffee of 3 L which makes it the best coffee carafe when it comes to capacity so far.

In addition, the lower part of this carafe is made from a stainless steel material that is extremely durable. It is also double-walled so as to offer better thermal properties. It has excellent heat retention of 12 hours for hot coffee and 24 hours for cold coffee which is more than respectable.

Also, what distinguishes this model from others is its coffee flow system which requires you to press on the handle above for coffee to flow.

This pump-action is very convenient especially if you want to prevent spillage from occurring as you do not have to tilt or even touch the carafe. Simply put, this carafe would have been perfect if it had a better price.

Pros:

  • It has a large capacity of 3 L
  • The long heat retention of 12 hours for hot and 24 hours for cold
  • Very easy-to-use with pump-action handle at the top

Cons:

  • The price. It is expensive

Notes

Due to the size of this coffee carafe, we recommend it for those who are heavy coffee drinkers or need a coffee carafe to serve multiple people. If not, there are smaller and more convenient carafes in this review

4. Keurig ​2.0 Thermal ​– Compatible with the Keurig 2.0 ​Brewing ​System

Keurig Double-Walled Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 1 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: Within 5 degrees for 30 minutes

The Keurig looks like a regular water kettle. But looks aside, this is a very decent coffee carafe that has a capacity of 1 L. ​But above all, it is fully compatible with the popular Keurig 2.0 brewing system that will allow you to make a tasty coffee with the push of a button.

You also have the choice between different colors as the Keurig is available in silver or black color to suit your kitchen color scheme. When it comes to design, this model uses a double-walled insulated vacuum to insulate the coffee from the outside.

Moreover, its stainless-steel build construction makes this carafe very durable and long-lasting. The lid is made from a high-grade plastic which is very easy to open and close with a simple push. In addition, the handle is also quite long and ergonomic, and you do not have to tilt the carafe to a steep angle for the coffee to start flowing from the spout.

However, due to its small capacity of 1 L, this model is only recommended for casual users. Also, its heat retention is not the best out there even if it has decent specs considering its price.

Pros:

  • Affordable. Value for money
  • Fully compatible with the Keurig 2.0 brewing system
  • Durable build construction from stainless steel

Cons:

  • Small capacity of 1 L
  • Not the best heat retention technology

Notes

This coffee carafe is fully compatible with the Keurig 2.0 brewing system if you have it

5. Bellemain Premium Thermal – Affordable ​and Good Value

Bellemain Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 2 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 13+ hours

What distinguishes the Bellemain from the rest of the competition is its extremely affordable price. Indeed, this unit is the best thermal coffee carafe in this review when it comes to price.

However, despite being quite affordable, it still does not sacrifice build construction as it is made from high-grade stainless steel that is very durable and long-lasting. Moreover, you will not experience any “burn zone” with this coffee carafe as it has a double insulated wall.

But what is more surprising is that this is a high-capacity coffee carafe with a capacity of 2 L. This means that it is able to serve multiple cups of coffee and can also retain the heat for 13+ hours.

Taking all those factors into account, this model by Bellemain remains the ideal choice for those who need a high-capacity coffee carafe for a low price. ​

The only problems we have with this carafe is its outer metal shell gets hot. You need to be careful when handling this unit. Also, it lacks the durability of other models.

Pros:

  • Very affordable. Value for money
  • High capacity of 2 L
  • Superb build construction from stainless steel. Durable and long-lasting

Cons:

  • ​The outer shell gets hot to the touch
  • Not the most durable

Notes

Due to the position and the design of the handle, you will need to turn this carafe to a steep angle before coffee starts flowing from the spout

6. Thermos Vacuum Insulated – ​Available in Different Sizes

Thermos Vacuum Insulated Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 1.5 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 12 hours hot and 24 hours cold

This Thermos coffee carafe is a high-capacity unit that can accommodate 1.5 L of coffee with ease. Moreover, ​this model is available in different sizes in case 1.5 L is too small or too big for your need.

Additionally, this product shines when it comes to versatility as it is available in a wide range of sizes to suit your need. It is built from a high-grade 18/8 stainless steel for both the interior as well as the exterior of the carafe. Therefore, this is a carafe that will last a long time and will also be very easy to clean.

Moreover, due to the design of the handle and top lid, you can easily use this unit with one hand only. Also, the spout has been designed in such a way that it will prevent coffee from spilling so you will be able to serve your coffee in a clean way using this top-rated coffee carafe.

The only negative we find with this thermos is the lid that is somewhat difficult to clean as it has internal parts that are not easily accessible.

Pros:

  • Flexible. Available in different sizes to suit your need
  • Excellent heat retention
  • Can easily be used with one hand
  • Outer shell stays cool to the hand even when filled with hot coffee

Cons:

  • The lid is difficult and complicated to clean

Notes

It is important to regularly clean this coffee carafe, or it may start affecting its heat retention

7. Panesor Thermal ​Insulated ​– Coffee ​Carafe that ​Retrofits as a ​Water ​Kettle

Panesor Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 1.7 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: N/A

The Panesor looks like a regular water heater. But it is so much more than that. This is a high-performing coffee carafe with a capacity of 1.7 L and a stainless-steel build construction for durability. What makes this model unique is that you can use it as a kettle to boil water as well.

This is because the interior, as well as the exterior, is made from 100% stainless steel which is very easy to clean and will not get affected by coffee over time.

Also, there are no plastic parts in this coffee carafe that comes in contact with your coffee so it will not develop any toxins.

Moreover, there is over-voltage protection in this coffee carafe, so the risk of a fire caused by a short circuit is very minimal. This model will also not boil when there is no liquid inside, even if the power button is pressed as it is equipped with a boil-dry protection feature.

Best, you can purchase this coffee carafe as both a white or gray color to match your kitchen’s color scheme. We only take issue with its high power usage of 1,500 W. If used regularly, it can add up quite a bit to your electrical cost.

Pros:

  • Available in different colors
  • Flexible. Can be used as a regular kettle as well
  • Double walled design for more efficient heating and heat retention
  • Blue LED light and ​auto shut off feature

Cons:

  • High power usage of 1,500 W

8. Genuine Joe GJO11956​ ​– ​Most Affordable Coffee Carafe

Genuine Joe GJO11956 Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 2 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 6 hours

The Genuine Joe is the most affordably priced coffee carafe in this review. Despite its very low price, it still sports a high capacity of 2 L and made from a stainless-steel shell which is durable and long-lasting.

Additionally, you can purchase this model as a single pack or a 2 pack if you need more than one item. When it comes to the handle, it is quite large and ergonomic, so you will have no difficulty serving coffee with this coffee carafe.

But what we like the most is the press-lever at the top that will prevent any accidental spillage of coffee. Indeed, for coffee to start flowing from the spout, you need to press this lever with your finger or else the spout will remain closed.

All in all, the Genuine Joe is definitely one of the best-insulated coffee carafes on the market, especially considering its very low price and high capacity. ​

Its heat retention of 6 hours is not as good when compared to other models we have reviewed so far. But, for the price, this is forgivable and still excellent!

Pros:

  • Very affordable. Value for money
  • High capacity of 2 L
  • Flexible. Available as a single or 2-pack
  • The secure lever on top of the lid to prevent accidental spillage

Cons:

  • The weak heat retention of 6 hours

Notes

Despite having a double wall design, the outer shell of this coffee carafe may get hot, so you need to be careful when handling it

9. Zojirushi AFB Premium​ ​– Easy to Handle with ​One ​Hand

Zojirushi AFB Premium Thermal Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 1 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 6 hours

The Zojirushi is a tall and slim coffee carafe that is easy to handle with one hand only. This model has a low capacity of 1 L, but it is still more than enough for casual use, especially for coffee drinkers who do not drink more than 4 cups of coffee every day.

Also, if you need a higher capacity model, then this unit is quite flexible as it is also available in a 1.85 L model. When it comes to construction, you have nothing to worry as it is made from stainless steel both in the inside as well as the outside for durability.

But what we like the most about this carafe is that it uses a thumb-button system on top of the led which means that you will have to press the top of the lid for the spout to open and coffee to flow. This is a great feature that will prevent accidental spillage of coffee.

The only problem we note with this carafe is that the lid mechanism is a bit fragile, and not the best design out there.

Pros:

  • Tall and slim. Easy to handle with one hand
  • Durable build construction from stainless steel
  • Flexible. Available in different sizes
  • Prevents coffee spillage by using a thumb-button system on the lid

Cons:

  • ​Not the best lid mechanism

10. Vremi ​VRM020037N ​– ​Aesthetically Pleasing and Available in Different Colors

Vremi 51 oz Coffee Carafe
  • Capacity: 1.5 L
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Heat Retention: 6 hours

When it comes to aesthetics, the Vremi is definitely its superior coffee carafe. It is available in different colors and has a shiny mirror-like finish that makes it look stunning.

This insulated coffee carafe is made from high-grade stainless steel both in the inside as well as the outside. Therefore, it is very easy to clean with a simple piece of microfiber cloth. Moreover, it uses a double-walled design so as to offer better thermal properties.

It is able to retain heat for 6 hours, which is not the best we have seen in this review but definitely more than enough for most people. It is an excellent choice for those looking for a striking coffee carafe that has a high-capacity and heat decent retention time.

Pros:

  • Aesthetically pleasing
  • Flexible. Available in different colors
  • Relatively high capacity of 1.5 L

Cons:

  • The average heat retention of 6 hours

Notes

This is a big carafe, so it is probably not the ideal choice for those looking for a portable coffee carafe

How to Buy the Best Coffee Carafes

How to Buy the Best Coffee Carafe

In order to help you find the best coffee carafe for the money, here are some important aspects to consider.

1. Capacity

Simply put, the capacity is how much coffee your coffee carafe is able to contain. For most people, a coffee carafe that has a capacity of 1 L is more than enough.

However, if you plan to be serving multiple people or you are a heavy coffee drinker then it is always best to think ahead and get a coffee carafe with a greater capacity of 2 L or more.

2. Material

The material used in the build construction of the coffee carafe is important. It will dictate both the aesthetics of the coffee carafe as well as its functionality.

Indeed, a coffee carafe made from plastic is usually lightweight and inexpensive.

On the other hand, it lacks the aesthetics and may look cheap which is not desired especially if you are planning to serve coffee to multiple people using the carafe.

A coffee carafe made from stainless steel is usually more aesthetically pleasing and more durable as well.

However, the main disadvantages of the coffee carafe made from stainless steel are that it is more expensive. But this is a trade-off that is most of the time well worth it!

3. Design

The design of the coffee carafe will dictate how easy it is to use as well as how functional the coffee carafe is. A coffee carafe that has a good design will also have a large and comfortable handle that is ergonomic to hold.

Additionally, you will not have to tilt your coffee carafe to a steep angle for the coffee to start flowing from the spout another carafe.

Another area where the design plays a huge role is in the inner design. Indeed, the inner design of the coffee carafe will dictate how well it is able to insulate the coffee from the surrounding air and provided with excellent heat retention.

Moreover, a well-designed coffee carafe will be cool on the exterior because it will have a double internal wall for superior thermal insulation.

In turn, this will prevent you from scalding your hand whenever you pour hot coffee in the carafe thus making it safer for anyone to use.

4. Easy to clean

Since you will be probably purchasing a coffee carafe that is made from stainless steel, it is important that it is easy to clean because a coffee carafe made from stainless steel is usually a fingerprint magnet.

Therefore, your carafe must be easy to clean with something as simple as either a dry or wet cloth.

5. Price

Even if the coffee carafe is not a very expensive coffee accessory, it is still important to pay attention to the price.

This is because the price of the coffee carafe can quickly get out of hand and there are models that are sold for hundreds of dollars while not having functionality or build construction to justify its price.

Therefore, stick to a specific budget when purchasing a coffee carafe.

6. Warranty

The coffee carafe is usually a very durable and heavy-duty accessory that last a long time. However, it is still prone to damage from time to time.

Therefore, it is important to go with a model that offers you a manufacturer warranty of at least one year or more.

Conclusion 

The coffee carafe is the only way you should serve coffee, whether you are a casual coffee drinker or an expert barista.

Above all, the coffee carafe is designed in such a way to keep your coffee hot and allows you to serve your brew without the risk of spillage.

Moreover, there is a wide range of coffee carafes on the market. They differ in shape, capacity, and prices.

So, regardless of your budget and need, you are more than likely to find a quality model by reading our coffee carafe review above. If you have not found a decent coffee carafe just yet, read the review again!